The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday denied a stay of execution for Thomas Overton, clearing the way for Florida to put him to death by lethal injection at 6 p.m. at Florida State Prison in Raiford. If carried out as scheduled, it will be the 20th execution in Florida this year, a state record.
Overton, 71, was convicted of the 1991 murders of Michael and Susan "Missy" MacIvor at their home in Tavernier, in the Florida Keys. Susan MacIvor, a 29-year-old teacher, was eight months pregnant; the unborn child did not survive. Overton has continued to maintain his innocence.
The denial on Thursday was the last of a series of rejected appeals. On November 13, the Florida Supreme Court denied Overton's motion to vacate his conviction and said there was "no need to stay Overton's execution," declining to rehear additional motions. His legal team then applied to the U.S. Supreme Court on November 14, citing repeated mishandling of evidence, false witness testimony and Florida's executive clemency process. The high court denied the stay application on Thursday without comment.
According to court records, Overton, then 35 and working at an Amoco gas station in Monroe County, broke into the MacIvors' home on August 22, 1991. He was sentenced to death in 1999 for the two murders, with additional terms for sexual battery, burglary and killing an unborn child. Postconviction appeals raised claims about the handling of evidence, the use of an Orlando psychic in the investigation, the strength of DNA results and testimony from jailhouse informants. The appeals were denied.
Florida's execution pace has risen sharply under Gov. Ron DeSantis. Before last year, the state's modern record was eight executions in a year. DeSantis issued 19 death warrants in 2025 after President Donald Trump issued an executive order in 2025 requiring federal prosecutors to seek the death penalty when possible and encouraging state attorneys general to do the same. The state tied that mark this year with the November 5 execution of Jesse Guardado, and Overton's scheduled execution would exceed it. Two more executions are already set: Ricardo Gonzalez on December 1 and Willie Seth Crain Jr. on December 19.
DeSantis has said the accelerated schedule is for victims and their families, who in some cases have waited decades. Opponents have asked incoming Gov. Byron Donalds to pause executions when he takes office in January. "Nobody chose this pace," the Rev. Jeff Hood, a spiritual adviser to both men scheduled for December, wrote to Donalds on November 11. "No legislature voted for it. No commission studied it. No voter was asked whether Florida should execute at this rate." Overton is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection beginning at 6 p.m. on Thursday under a death warrant signed October 21.


