The Department of Homeland Security went too far in loosening training standards for thousands of immigration officers hired to support President Donald Trump's mass deportation push, an internal department watchdog has found in a draft report, The New York Times reported on November 20.

The findings, in a 19-page draft report from the Department of Homeland Security's Office of Inspector General that has not been finalized or released, amount to a sweeping critique of the plan carried out under Kristi Noem, the homeland security secretary at the time, to rapidly hire and deploy 10,000 new officers with tens of billions of dollars provided by Congress, according to the Times' account of the draft. One recruit instructor quoted in the draft report, which was obtained by the Times, called the rollbacks in training standards a "catastrophic failure," the Times reported. The report is a draft, and its figures could change before a final version is released.

Nearly 6,000 officers received reduced training between August 2025 and July 2026, according to the draft as reported by the Times. More than 3,500 recruits with prior law enforcement experience were allowed to complete basic training virtually instead of attending a monthlong in-person program, the Times reported. More than 80 percent of those recruits finished the online coursework within 10 days, more than 10 percent in under 24 hours, and at least five in about two hours, according to the draft as reported.

For recruits with no law enforcement experience, ICE cut training from 543 hours to around 300 hours, and the number of training days went down from 72 to 42, the Times reported, with the cuts made beginning in November 2025 until February 2026. Reported cuts touched firearms, arrest procedures, driving and determining citizenship, according to accounts of the draft. The draft also criticized the relaxing of a policy that had given recruits only two chances to pass a training test, the Times reported, citing one officer who reportedly took the test 32 times before passing. Nearly 90 percent of ICE officials who ran on-the-job training and answered the watchdog's questionnaire said that program was not successful, according to the draft as reported.

The draft says former Secretary Kristi Noem and adviser Corey Lewandowski strongly supported the reductions, and ICE's former training chief told investigators he was ordered to carry them out, according to the Times' account. Inspector general agents struggled to determine the rationale of department leaders in justifying the slimmed-down training because the leaders "did not leave behind any written explanation for their decision," the draft report said, according to the Times. Top ICE officials believed the training changes were a mistake, according to a former senior official who spoke to the Times on condition of anonymity to discuss the findings in the draft report.

The draft noted that the current secretary, Markwayne Mullin, restored the more robust training standards in July, the Times reported. However, it said, "despite increasing training hours and days for future recruits, ICE has not fully addressed training gaps born of the reductions and revisions," according to the Times. The draft report did not consider whether lax training had contributed to problems on the ground, the Times reported. The report landed two days after Mullin told the House Homeland Security Committee that officers who have not completed full background checks or the full 13-week training are on administrative leave, according to reporting on the November 18 hearing.

The Homeland Security Department's inspector general, Joseph V. Cuffari, is one of the few internal agency watchdogs Trump did not dismiss after retaking office, the Times reported. "We strongly condemn the premature release of draft reports before the department has had the opportunity to complete its review and provide formal comments," Cuffari's office said in a statement, according to the Times. DHS told the Times that officers are receiving additional training, and ICE stressed that many of the new hires already had law enforcement backgrounds and had completed police academies, according to accounts of the reporting. The inspector general's formal recommendations and ICE's response are not yet public, and it remains unclear whether ICE will retrain the roughly 6,000 officers who went through shortened programs or only apply the restored standards to new hires.